How to Check Your Home Insurance Score for Free
No single free score exists. Check your credit report and your CLUE claims history, the two factors insurers actually use.
Free to compare
Why your renewal went up with no claim filed
A higher renewal with nothing changed on the house usually comes down to factors that have nothing to do with you personally. Insurers reprice based on rebuilding costs in your area, which have climbed with materials and labor, and on claims other homeowners nearby have filed, like storm or water damage. Your own credit-based insurance score and your CLUE report matter too, and both can shift without you doing anything wrong. A late payment years ago, or a claim filed by a previous owner of your house, can sit on these reports longer than people expect. Pull both and check them against what you know to be true. If the increase still looks out of line with your risk, that's the point where comparing other insurers makes sense, since the same facts can price very differently from one company to the next.
The same house, priced differently elsewhere
Your credit score and claims history are fixed for now, but the price an insurer builds from them isn't. Another insurer weighing the same facts can land on a lower number.
What actually sits on a CLUE report and a credit report
A CLUE report covers the last seven years and lists claims by address and by person, not just by policy. That matters if you bought the house recently. A water damage claim the previous owner filed three years ago can still show up and still affect how an insurer prices your policy, even though you had nothing to do with it. The report also logs claims you inquired about but never filed, in some cases, so a call to a prior insurer asking what a repair might cost can leave a mark that looks like a claim to the next company that pulls your file.
Your credit-based insurance score isn't the same number as your credit score, though it's built from the same credit report. It weighs payment history, how much available credit you're using, length of credit history, and recent inquiries, but it weighs them differently than a lender would. Insurers use this score because, as a group, it has a measurable statistical relationship to how often people file claims. That's the industry's justification for using it, whether or not it describes your particular case. A few states don't allow insurers to use credit for home insurance pricing at all, so check whether yours is one of them before you assume this factor applies to you.
Both reports can carry errors. A late payment that was actually paid on time, a claim logged under your address from before you owned the house, an account that isn't yours at all. These happen more often than people expect, and they don't correct themselves. You're entitled to a free copy of your credit report from each of the three bureaus once a year, and a free copy of your CLUE report through the same kind of request. If you find something wrong, both the credit bureau and LexisNexis, which runs the CLUE database, have dispute processes, though they can take weeks to resolve.
None of this tells you whether your current price is competitive, only whether it's accurate. Those are different questions. A correct CLUE report and an accurate credit score still get run through each insurer's own formula, and formulas vary enough that two companies can look at the identical file and land on prices that differ by hundreds of dollars a year. Fixing an error might lower your score. It won't tell you what another insurer would have charged you from the start.
How to actually pull both reports
Your credit report comes from three bureaus, Equifax, Experian and TransUnion, and you're entitled to a free copy from each once a year through annualcreditreport.com. That site is the one the Federal Trade Commission points to, and it won't try to sell you a credit monitoring subscription on the way in. Pull all three. Insurers don't all use the same bureau, and the three reports don't always match.
Your CLUE report is separate and comes from LexisNexis, the company that runs the claims database insurers report into. You can request it directly through LexisNexis, either online or by phone, and you're entitled to a free copy once a year under the same federal law that covers credit reports. If you've never requested one, ask for it even if nothing seems wrong. It's the only way to see what insurers are actually seeing when they price your renewal.
Give yourself time before your renewal date to do this. Both reports can take a few days to arrive, and if you find an error, the dispute process runs on weeks, not days. Starting a month or two before your policy renews means you have something to work with before the new price is locked in, rather than after. If your renewal already arrived and the increase looks steep, you can still request both reports now and use what you find for next year, or as a reason to compare other insurers today.
Keep in mind that neither report updates the moment something changes. A dispute you win today may not show up on the version an insurer already pulled for this renewal cycle. That's part of why an error, once found, is worth fixing regardless of this year's price. It sits on your file until you correct it, and it will keep showing up to every insurer who looks, this year and next.
Before your renewal date comes around again
Pull your credit report and your CLUE report now, while you have time to dispute anything wrong before the next renewal is set. Then see what another insurer makes of the same file.
